OK we all know by now that the Aardman Animation's prop and set warehouse was utterly destroyed by fire early last week. We know that the entire history of Aardman was wiped out. We remember how DreamWorks interfered with the creation of Chicken Run, driving the animators to distraction,and ensuring that CR wouldn't do as well as Aardman had hoped--So...we know how much was riding on W&G: TCotWR.
The critics are hailing the film, and it opened at #1 in the U.S. the week it debuted. So, I'll be the first to say: I hope that Aardman makes buku bucks on this film...but...as good as it is, it isn't as good as Chicken Run. Why? Because it's not a movie. It's a set of Wallace & Gromit shorts strung together.
Sure this thing is clever, the pace is frenetic, and the gags are non-stop. In fact, Aardman has put in place some of the funniest site-gags they've ever committed to film. But Wallace is no longer smart in that sort of irritating British way, he's just irritating. Gromit is timid not endearing. IMHO, the best part of the film is Victor Quartermaine (voice of Ralph Fiennes) and not...Gromit, and that's definitely not a good thing.
Chicken Run had characters. W&G has caricatures.
Basically, I walked out of the theatre saying to myself, "OK, I've now seen 6 Wallace & Gromit shorts. I hope they don't make any more." Sadly, after the fire, Aardman may not have a choice on the issue.